Note that this article appeared on March 7
www.dailyherald.com/story/?id=149007Mobile classrooms a health risk? Officials not worried
By Kerry Lester | Daily Herald Staff
Published: 3/7/2008 12:19 AM
A number of Bartlett parents have raised concerns about the long-term health effects of mobile classrooms.
As part of the group's request Monday that Elgin Area School District U-46 board remove two mobile units from Nature Ridge school, Beverly Jaszczurowski cited a Centers for Disease Control study released Feb. 14.
The study found higher-than-typical indoor levels of formaldehyde in travel trailers and mobile homes provided to displaced victims of Hurricane Katrina.
"Long-term exposure to levels in this range can be linked to an increased risk of cancer, and as levels rise above this range, there can also be a risk of respiratory illness," the study said.
Jaszczurowski, a mother of a Nature Ridge kindergartner, suggested students attending class in mobiles for upward of six hours a day could suffer similar health effects as those in Katrina trailers.
"There are serious long-term effects of kids breathing in formaldehyde. … It's not healthy for anyone. It's just not safe," she said.
Nichelle Rivers, associate superintendent for health and life safety issues at the Cook County Regional Department of Education, says she had never heard of formaldehyde leaks in trailers until the CDC report came out.
"Parents are parents, and they're going to make a connection between mobile classrooms and mobile homes," Rivers said. "But I wouldn't compare mobile classrooms to these trailers."
Kane County Regional Superintendent Doug Johnson echoed Rivers thoughts.
"I can tell you, the school districts all want to get rid of these as soon as we can," Johnson said. "But mobile classrooms are very different from the Katrina trailers. … Those would never be approved to be used in schools to begin with."
About 112 of Nature Ridge's 800 students attend classes in mobile units, Principal Terri Lozier said. With a projected enrollment of 850 students, three more mobile units are expected to be added next year.
According to district data, 95 classrooms are set up in 64 mobile units.
Bartlett, Larkin and Streamwood high schools each have mobile units, as do Canton Middle School and 17 elementary schools.
Jaszczurowski implored the board to have a long-term plan.
"We will move before my children are schooled in U-46 trailers," she said Monday.
Both the Cook and Kane County Regional Department of Education make annual inspections to schools that feature mobile classrooms.
"An architect first comes out to do an inspection of each of the units," Rivers said. County officials then do their own inspection to check the architect's work.
Rivers recommended U-46 parents "ask the district to come in and conduct a check. Have an outside consultant come in and inspect the units safety," she said.
A capital planning study, to focus on space and capacity, hopes to minimize the use of -- and spending on -- mobile classroom units throughout the district.
The district's last capital planning study was completed in 1998. The new study will be completed by December.
With a projected enrollment next year of 850 students, Nature Ridge is expected to get three more mobile classrooms for the 2008-09 school year.
"We'll do what we have to do for the best of kids," Lozier said. "If we do get three more mobiles in next year, we'll make it work."